In this last of five Nature Videos from this year's Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting on Physiology and Medicine Nobel laureate Oliver Smithies talks with Diego Bohórquez from Duke University (USA) about being hungry for knowledge.
Oliver Smithies, 2007 Nobel Prize in Physiology
or Medicine Diego Bohórquez, Duke University, USA
Elizabeth Blackburn grew up in Hobart on the Australian island of Tasmania. It was a long journey from there to a Nobel prize and the lab she runs at the University of California in San Francisco. Malaria researcher Clare Smith is also a Hobart girl, and she’s trying to decide whether to follow in Blackburn’s footsteps and move overseas after she finishes her PhD. Karina Zillner is from Germany. Like Clare, she’s in the final stages of a PhD. She’s developed a method for analysing sections of repetitive DNA. Karina hopes her Eltechnique might be used in Blackburn’s lab, where they study telomeres — repetitive sections of DNA that protect the ends of chromosomes.
(More)
Camelia-Lucia Cimpianu is trying to decide between a career as a researcher or a practising doctor. In this film, she seeks advice from Nobel Laureate Ferid Murad who faced the same dilemma as a medical student in the 1960s. Murad chose the bench, and he subsequently discovered that a gas called nitric oxide (NO) acts as a signalling molecule in the cardiovascular system. It turns out that NO plays a role in many diseases — and possibly in the head trauma cases that Camelia studies.
Ferid Murad, 1998 Nobel Prize in Physiology or
Medicine
Camelia-Lucia Cimpianu, University of
Erlangen-Nurnberg, Germany
In the next video of the Nature video team in cooperation with the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings Nobel laureate Eddi Fischer talks to a young researcher from China, Tong Qing, about ways to combat cancer.
As last year, the Nature video team in cooperation with the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meetings filmed discussions between one or two young researchers and a Nobel laureate about current research topics in Physiology and Medicine, the world’s greatest health challenges and how to tackle them. Today we may present the trailer and the first of five such videos.
The young researchers the team follows in these films are working on malaria, cancer, viruses and more. They are also learning how to be scientists; how to write grant applications, how to collaborate with other research groups, and how to find the right career path. See what advice the laureates offer — and what questions the laureates have for them. (More)
Last year saw the introduction of a new session at the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting – the “Turning the Tables” discussion that took place on Wednesday afternoon. Originally a specially recorded session that was featured in a Nature Outlook supplement, the idea behind this 90-minute slot is to move away from the plenaries and afternoon forums where the laureates are the sole focus of the spotlight, and instead to create a conversation where the young scientists themselves can share the stage.
This year’s session involved a similar set-up to the initial experiment – six PhD students and three laureates, chaired this year by Scientific American’s Steve Mirsky, answered a series of informal questions about what it’s like to be a scientist. The students came from a variety of locations including Nigeria, India, Colombia and the US while the all-male laureates were Peter Agre, Thomas Steitz and Torsten Wiesel. The discussions were framed as a chance to compare notes on how scientific practice might have changed since the laureates were themselves starting off on the scientific path, and also whether there are any noticeable differences that arise from where you study.
In 1969, one of
the more memorable incidents in the public advocacy of science took
place. The American physicist Robert Wilson was asked to testify
before Congress in support of the construction of the Fermi National
Accelerator Laboratory, known as Fermilab. For Wilson, building this
huge machine had been a labor of love and nobody had a better background for it. He had worked on the Manhattan Project
where he was the youngest group leader in the experimental division, and after the war he had become a professor at Cornell University.
Wilson
was a first-rate amateur architect who saw accelerators as works of
art. He lovingly designed Fermilab with his own hands and, in order to
add to the aesthetic appeal of the place, turned the surrounding acres
into a wilderness housing bison and geese. His efforts paid off; Fermilab would become the largest accelerator in the United States and CERN's primary competitor. In 1969 Wilson was asked to
justify the expenditure for the multi-million dollar laboratory in front
of Congress. The Cold War was raging, most research and especially
physics research was being viewed in the context of national security,
and Wilson was specifically asked what contribution the new laboratory
would make to national defense. He replied in words that should be
etched on the foundation stone of every center of basic research. The
research, he said, had no direct bearing on national defense. Instead,
It
has only to do with the respect with which we regard one another, the
dignity of men, our love of culture. It has to do with: Are we good
painters, good sculptors, great poets? I mean all the things we really
venerate in our country and are patriotic about. It has nothing to do
directly with defending our country except to make it worth defending.
In the daily morning plenary lectures at Lindau, the Nobel laureates have a chance both to share the significance of their discoveries, and also words of advice for the young scientists eager to follow in their footsteps. During the course of the week, the audience is taken on a week-long tour of the ultimate scientific scrapbook as each page is lovingly turned by one narrator after another. Working models of data, scribbled pages from lab books, personal anecdotes, family photos and even famous quotations illuminate what it means to be a scientist for the different speakers. (More)
The final day of this year's Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting involved the customary boat trip to Isle of Mainau, where this year the Closing Panel Discussion focused on the issue of "Global Health."
To capture the live tweeting around these sessions, as well as video and blog content, we have created a Storify storyboard. We'll continue to update it as more coverage is published so you might want to bookmark it and check back again later to make sure you don't miss anything.
We've created storyboards for each day of the conference, so don't forget to check out coverage from Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday.
and Thursday too.
Can one appreciate the deep beauty of science, without mastering calculus, quantum mechanics or molecular genetics? I reckon the answer is yes, but I know at least one Nobel laureate disagrees with me.
Sir Harry Kroto made the following comparison during a tense press conference on Wednesday: “Try to explain the culture and the depth of Shakespeare to someone who does not speak the English language. It’s extremely difficult. When a journalist asks me to describe my research in one sentence, I get irritated and ask: ‘how much of the language of science do you know?’”
What can be done about global health? It's the question on everyone's minds following Peter Agre's moving talk on malaria 'without borders' earlier in the week and Christian De Duve handing the baton of all the world's challenges to the young researchers in the last lecture: "Our generation has made a mess of it... the future is in your hands".
The need is clear: Better diagnostic tools, as discussed in the panel on the future of biomedicine, will be for people that can afford them. The Economist's science and technology editor Geoffrey Carr starts the concluding panel of the Lindau meeting by setting out the stark reality: "The greatest health needs are in the developing countries".
Hans Rosling, professor of International Health at the Karolinska Institute in Sweden, and the founder of the Gapminder Foundation, kicks off the debate presenting an animated graph showing how life expectancy and fertility have changed over time for each country. He says that in the 60s, there was a clear 'developing' and 'developed' world division with people in the developing world having big families and short lives, and the opposite for rich countries. Rosling uses the case of Bangladesh to illustrate his point: In the 60s, it was typical of a developing country, but by 2006 the child fertility rate is 2.3 children and people are living longer because of better healthcare. "People say the world isn't getting better... that's bullshit," he exclaims.
Kelly Quesnelle: I came to Lindau as many students nearing the end of their doctoral studies: somewhat disillusioned by the tenacious nature of academic science that I have come to realize in graduate school and in search of inspiration for my future.
The penultimate day of this year's Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting began with a morning of plenary sessions by four of the Laureates followed by a panel discussion on, "Being a (Responsible) Scientist."
To capture the live tweeting around these talks, as well as video and blog content, we have created a Storify storyboard. Do check back as we'll be updating it as more coverage is published. There are also individual Storifys for Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday.
(More)
This is the 61th year that the Nobel Laureate Meetings have been held at Lindau. The conference was held for the first time in 1951, funded by the wealthy count Lennart Bernadotte, as an effort to restore the international scientific ties that had been severed by the war. The count’s daughter, Bettina Bernadotte, has been the patron of the Lindau Conferences since 2007. The different institutions and countries usually offer the countess a gift, to thank her for her hospitality. But the American delegation do things differently this year.
(More)
...of the Lindau Meeting of Nobel Laureates. The last meeting was dedicated to Physiology or Medicine and took place from June 26 till July 1, 2011. Our team from the Lindau office, Nature and Spektrum together with bloggers, the film crew, as well as attendees reported and report from this extraordinary science meeting. 25 Nobel Laureates and 570 young researchers from 80 countries discussed and exchanged ideas for one week and there are still more stories to tell. Special stories, interviews and videos will follow.
The Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting
Nature Outlook
This Nature Outlook examines the areas of biomedical science that challenge and inspire the pre-eminent investigators who joined the Lindau Nobel Laureate Meeting on Physiology or Medicine in 2011.
Lindau Blogger Profiles
Beatrice Lugger
Lucas Brouwers
Lou Woodley
Christine Ottery
Ashutosh Jogalekar
Yvonne Buchholz
Felix Man Ho Cheung
Lars Fischer
Tobias Maier
Marcus Jahnel
Online Dialogue
Teilnehmer
Attendees
Bloguero invitado
Guest blogger
Live Twitter Feed
If you tweet about the Lindau meeting, please use the hashtag #lnlm11.
12. October 2011, 18:36
1 Comment(s)